Case of the Week: March 31-April 7, 2011

Finding and two or three differential diagnosis for the finding?

(Click for a larger image.)

Case Details

Study demonstrates shortened 4th and 5th metacarpal bones.


Diagnosis: Short fourth and fifth metacarpals-Idiopathic

When a line is drawn along  the heads of the 4th and 5th metacarpals, it should not intersect the  3rd metacarpal.  If it does the 4th metacarpal is shortened.

These bones can be shortened in a number of conditions, the most common of which is idiopathic as in this case.

Up to 9.6% of the population has this finding.

Shortened 4th and 5th metacarpals also occur in a number of conditions such as post-traumatic/post-infectious, Turner syndrome, pseudohypoparathyroidism, pseudopseudo- hypoparathyroidism, Basal cel nevus(Gorlin) syndrome, Sickle cell disease with infarction, Hereditary multiple exostosis and homocystinuria.

Correct answers by users

VCU Resident
Radiology Pediatrics
  • Charlotte Cockrell
  • Jonathan Ha
  • Madison McCulloch
  • Jamil Muasher
  • Jim Rittimann
  • Samantha Pollard
  • Fahri AyzitTurkey
  • Monika BagadeIndia
  • Georgios BarmpaliosGreece
  • Todd BerryUnited States of America
  • Seeta DuttaIndia
  • Rasha ElshafeyEgypt
  • John FahrnerUnited States of America
  • Sanjeeva GoliTrinidad and Tobago
  • Shailesh GuptaIndia
  • Omar HassanienEgypt
  • Oussama IsmaeelSyrian Arab Republic
  • Ramazan JafariIran
  • Ignasius JapparSingapore
  • Imran JindaniIndia
  • Manoj JohnIndia
  • Amit KardileIndia
  • John KirkhamUnited States of America
  • Naganathan ManiUnited States of America
  • Eman MarieEgypt
  • Raghu MurthyIndia
  • Aaron NordgrenUnited States of America
  • Robert PalmerUnited States of America
  • Suhasini PokanatiIndia
  • S RajeshIndia
  • Garrick ShermanUnited States of America
  • Christine SmithAustralia
  • Bradley SpielerUnited States of America
  • Rosmarie ValentaAustria
  • Trevor WatkinsAustralia
  • Ming YangUnited States of America
    VCU Department of Pediatric Radiology Virginia Commonwealth University VCU Medical Center